The Skin Stapler…..

What it does, it does well, but we’ve seen it done better elsewhere

The Skin Stapler isn’t a bad game. In fact, there are quite a few things here that I genuinely enjoyed. The puzzles are probably its strongest feature, and the core gameplay does enough to keep things moving without relying entirely on cheap scares or endless walking through dark corridors. When the game gets the balance right, exploring locations, investigating what happened and working out how to progress can be genuinely satisfying.

The problem is that very little of it feels new.

Retro-inspired horror games using PSX-style visuals, VHS slasher influences and deliberately rough presentation are everywhere now. The Skin Stapler clearly understands that style and executes it well, but it rarely pushes beyond what other games in the genre have already done. The grimy city, the serial-killer investigation, the exaggerated characters and the switch between detective work and survival horror all fit together, but almost every element feels familiar.

That familiarity wouldn’t necessarily be a problem if the game consistently delivered something exceptional, but it never quite reaches that level. Other indie horror games have created stronger scares, more memorable stories and smoother gameplay from very similar ideas. The Skin Stapler has its own setting and characters, but the overall experience still feels like a collection of influences that I have seen handled better elsewhere.

The puzzles were what kept me most engaged. They give you an actual reason to explore and pay attention, and they help break up the more straightforward sections. There is a decent sense of progression when you work something out and move the investigation forward. I appreciated that the game wanted me to do more than simply walk from one scripted scare to another.

At the same time, the gameplay can occasionally become frustrating. Some sections don’t feel quite as smooth or satisfying as they should, and there are moments where the mechanics get in the way of the tension rather than supporting it. None of these issues completely ruined the experience, and there wasn’t one major problem that made me want to stop playing, but the smaller frustrations do add up.

That is probably the best way to describe The Skin Stapler as a whole: it is solid, competently made and enjoyable in places, but it doesn’t leave a particularly strong impression once it is over. It knows exactly what kind of game it wants to be, and it delivers that experience without any major disasters. It just plays things too safely and relies heavily on ideas that the indie horror scene has been using for years.

If you’re a big fan of retro-styled horror, serial-killer stories and puzzle-focused exploration, there is still something here worth experiencing. The developers clearly understand the genre, and what the game does well, it does genuinely well. Just don’t go into it expecting a major reinvention of PSX horror or something that will completely surprise you.

WildStarGaming Score: ⭐⭐⭐☆☆

I would still recommend The Skin Stapler if you are already a fan of the genre and this style of visual. Just go in with the right expectation: this is not really a horror game in the traditional sense. It is more of a detective adventure with horror undertones, using its setting and presentation to create a dark atmosphere rather than delivering consistent scares. If that sounds like your sort of thing, and you are a fan of this style of game, there is enough here to enjoy, even if it never quite reaches the heights of the games it borrows from.

Contact us on our social media and don’t forget to listen to our weekly podcast